Source: The Scotsman, 6th January 1925
RUN OF THE GAME.Aberdeen began in promising style, and Forbes shot over after forcing play on the right. Hibs retaliated, and from an obviously offside position Walker sent wide. On the ice-bound surface the players had to go warily, and the use of restraint was not only excusable, but sensible, in the circumstances. Ritchie caused a flutter in the home camp when he dashed in and shot with his left foot, Blackwell gathering and clearing with decision. Play veered round in favour of Aberdeen, and after W. Jackson had a try blocked, and following upon this Harper saved from Forbes's head. Later the home inside left twice tested Scotland's goalkeeper with good tries, and after further pressure by Aberdeen J. Jackson just missed with first-time drive. The game was in need of something to liven it up, and when Halligan got in a powerful shot Blackwell did well to save. With twenty minutes played, Hibs got a corner-kick. It looked to badly placed by Walker, and yet the ball landed short of the goal, and bounced into the net without another player having touched it. Edward went to meet the ball from the flag-kick, but, evidently thinking it was going behind, left it, and so put Blackwell off his guard. It was the first goal scored direct from a corner since the rule was amended, but was a tremendous fluke. Hibs were adapting themselves better to the conditions, and, keeping the play open, were more dangerous, even if not attacking frequently as Aberdeen. A ball from Ritchie was misheaded for a corner by Hutton, and Walker nearly repeated his earlier feat from the flag, but on this occasion the ball curled on to the top of the net. Little was being seen of the Aberdeen forwards, Smith alone doing anything of note. Hibs continued to be the same dangerous lot, and Shaw just missed with a free kick which Miller had feinted to take. In another raid the Edinburgh forwards tested Blackwell from long range. Aberdeen had spasmodic attacks, but were never really dangerous, the forwards failing to adapt themselves to the ground conditions. The second half opened quietly, but the Hibernian attack maintained the stronger threat, although only "byes"' resulted. It was left to W. Jackson to have Aberdeen's first try, but his direction was bad, as was Forbes's when the latter nullified sustained Aberdeen pressure. Smith brightened up the game when he lifted over a centre and Harper had to run out and fist clear. Later J. Jackson forced his way past three opponents but, hampered, shot wide. Harper was again in action when he ran out and fielded from Forbes. Play continued to be in Aberdeen's favour, but there was a lack of punch in attack, and with the Edinburgh defence covering well Harper had nothing to test his abilities. Pretty much the same story was told when Hibs took up the attack. Forwards were not inclined to risk much, with the result that defenders got matters pretty much their own way. Walter Jackson worked in to deliver a fast grounder, which Harper saved, and then Templeton was lucky to get in the way of what must have been a sure counting shot by the same Aberdeen forward. Play was seldom away from Hibernian territory, but McGinnigle and Templeton defended splendidly. W. Jackson tried a shot from 35 yards, but Harper saved easily. He was more seriously tested later when he jumped up and cleared from a corner kick by Alec Jackson. Ultimately Hibs got away, and Dunn was very near with a fast cross-shot. On the eve of the final whistle Aberdeen almost equalised. Walter Jackson heading against the crossbar off a free kick taken by Edward. It was Aberdeen's game as far as pressure went, but the half-backs failed to keep the ball low and the forwards never combined well. A draw would have been a fair result, neither team was worthy of a goal, and that which fell Hibs was a fluke.
Source: Press & Journal, 6th January 1925