Source: The Scotsman, 9th February 1925
OUTSTANDING PLAYERS.The Aberdeen defence played very soundly. Blackwell had many anxious moments, but came out of the game with credit as did D. Bruce and Forsyth at back. This pair had a busy afternoon, but their tackling and sure kicking was first class. Hutton was most prominent in a good half-hack line, and put in a powerful afternoon's work. In attack the most prominent were R. Bruce, Smith, and A. Jackson. The first-named was probably the best dribbler on the field, but there was a tendency on his part to retain possession too long, although the conditions favoured the individual player. Smith got over a number of very dangerous centres, and it was his clever work that made it easy for Pirie to head the equalising goal. Armadale put up a surprisingly good display against more fancied opponents, and although Aberdeen ought to win the replay at Pittodrie on Wednesday, the West Lothian team will assuredly offer stout resistance. They have a capable goalkeeper in Davies, and in Scullion and Shaw a pair of backs who are dour fighters, strong kickers, and resolute tacklers. Duff, a big, left half, was one of the best individual successes in the game. Not only did he defend well, but repeatedly forced the war Into the enemy's territory. In a swift-moving attack, who proved capable exponents of the swinging game, Chisholm, Leith, and Paterson were outstanding. The supporters of the Armadale were delighted with the play of their team, and at the close were openly optimistic regarding its chances in the replay at Aberdeen.
A PERIOD OF THRILLS.Both teams took some time to find their feet, but Aberdeen were first on the offensive. A. Jackson made headway and centred, and, W. Jackson with a first-time shot hit the ball high over the bar and out of the ground. Chisholm on the Armadale left made progress, and centred, and Paterson, when in favourable position, negatived the advantage by handling. Off the free kick, Aberdeen again attacked, and Hutton sent a 'free' against a wall of defenders, Bruce sending high from the rebound. Davies at full length saved a lightning shot by Smith, and after a scrimmage the ball was got away. A dash by Duff led to Paterson netting, but the whistle had previously sounded for an infringement. Aberdeen were again aggressive, but the forwards were affected bby the narrowness of the pitch, and the home backs smashed up attack after attack. With twelve minutes gone Armadale took the lead. Chisholm broke away and transferred to the right, for Leitch to return the ball and shoot into the net from close range. Aberdeen followed with a desperate attack, and Edward headed over. R. Bruce followed with a shot that went wide. Subsequently the Armadale forwards again got going, but D. Bruce and Forsyth defended well. At the home end Pirie and W. Jackson were robbed when about to shoot, and R. Bruce dribbled through to send past. The latter should have equalised after this, when he swung at but completely missed a ground pass by A. Jackson. All the play was near Davies' goal at this stage, but Armadale crowded their defence into the penalty area, and may balls that might have found the net were blocked or charged down. A. Jackson dribbled through and cut in to shoot, only to miss the goal by inches. Pressure told, and after 25 minutes' play Aberdeen drew level. Smith obtained possession near midfield, and, racing ahead, out-distanced Young and Shaw. When two yards short of the goal line, he stopped suddenly, and with his pursuers running past him, was left clear to centre. He took full advantage of the opportunity, and lobbed the ball across for Pirie to head it downwards and into net. In the following minutes Aberdeen surged round the home goal. R. Bruce shot over after fine play by A. Jackson, and Davies saved a fast ground shot by W. Jackson. Smith, on the Aberdeen left was a great source of danger. Off another centre by him, Pirie headed inches wide of the goal, and just failed to get his foot on another lobbed cross from the Aberdeen left winger. Following a free kick taken by Duff, the ball flashed across the Aberdeen goal to go narrowly behind. Aberdeen forced the game until the interval, but although Davies was often in action, and had an anxious time dealing with corner kicks, the Armadale defence held out, and there was no further scoring.
ABERDEEN STRETCHED.Armadale got quickly to grips with the Aberdeen defence on resuming. A shot by Ashton was deflected for a corner, but Leitch failed to keep the ball in play. A raid by A. Jackson was negatived by his being charged over the touchline. By kick and rush football Armadale again attacked, but were met by a resolute defence. Smith gave relief with a dash, and forced a corner, but the ball was got away. R. Bruce was accidentally kicked on the chin and had to be attended off the field. He was, however, soon able to resume. Davies saved from A. Jackson's head, and at the other end Hutton effected a great recovery when Ashton was on the point of shooting. The home forwards played with great dash, and following a corner forced by Leitch, Dick headed wide. A ball from Smith at the home end was dropped at Pirie's feet by the, goalkeeper, but the centre-forward skied, and a splendid chance of taking the lead was lost. For a time after this the Aberdeen wingers were busy, but they were unable to judge distance, and their crosses carried too far. Following a foul against Hutton, Blackwell had an anxious time. He saved in quick succession from Freel and Chisholm, and, finally, Armadale forced a corner for Hutton to bring relief. The Aberdeen attack again came into prominence and Davies, at full length, effected a wonderful save from Smith. But the home team showed no signs of relaxing their efforts in attack. They swarmed into the Aberdeen penalty area, and Bruce, Forsyth, and Hutton had a trying ordeal. On several occasions they only got in their clearances in the nick of time and once Bruce brought off a wonderful bit of work when he punted clear with several forwards rushing him. Aberdeen got temporary relief when Pirie dashed away, but Scullion dispossessed him with only Davies in front. R, Bruce, who was the cleverest individualist afield, dribbled half the length of the pitch and forced a corner, but Duff came to the rescue. Towards the end, both teams showed signs of tiring, but they maintained a relentless duel. Following a free kick, Chisholm missed Blackwell's goal by inches, and at the other end, W. Jackson and R. Bruce both shot wide. Davies saved a fast ground ball from Smith, and, near the finish, Aberdeen packed their goal to get rid of a flag kick taken by Chisholm. A game full of exciting passages finished without addition to the score. The number who paid for admission was 6600, and the receipts, exclusive of stand and tax, amounted to£260.
THE REPLAY.The replay will take place at Pittodrie Park on Wednesday afternoon, and, to allow of extra time being played if necessary, the kick-off will at 2 40 p.m. Although several of the Aberdeen players are feeling the effects of Aberdeen's gruelling game, all are expected to be fit, and it is unlikely that there will be any changes in the team. In all likelihood Armadale will field the same side, except that McAdam may take the place of Ashton at inside left. Mr T. Small, Dundee, will again have charge of the tie.
Source: Press & Journal, 9th February 1925