Source: The Scotsman, 7th November 1927
PLAYERS INJURED.The whole team gave a most disappointing display. In part extenuation, it might be put forward that Cosgrove was injured early in the game, and was badly lamed, going to outside right, with Love as partner and Cheyne at right half, but this circumstance was counter-balanced by the fact that O'Hare, the Thistle right back, and Ness, outside right, were also lame for a considerable period of the game and actually retired about five minutes from the close, so that the winners finished with nine men.
FAST SCORING.About 11,000 people witnessed Aberdeen's eclipse. Thistle attacked at the opening, and Salisbury, when well placed, sent weakly behind after Blackwell had cleared. A home success was not long delayed, however, after five minutes Salisbury tricked Jackson to centre, and Ness headed into the net. Immediately afterwards, Elliot from long range shot against Blackwell's crossbar. After eight minutes' play the Aberdeen defence failed to clear, and McDougall shot a second goal while falling to the ground. Even this second reverse did not stir Aberdeen, and after ten minutes' play Grove got a third goal for Thistle with a fine shot. Following this the visitors rallied, and the Thistle goalkeeper was frequently in action. A slip by O'Hare nearly let Smith through, but the defender recovered, and shortly afterwards Thistle went further ahead. Salisbury crossed, and with the Pittodrie defence in a muddle, Williamson shot and the ball struck Ritchie on the knee, to be deflected past Blackwell. Subsequently Aberdeen were kept busy defending, but their troubles were added to when Cosgrove was injured and had to be carried off. He returned later and went outside right, but in his crippled state was of little further use to his side. Ten minutes from the interval McDougall got a fifth goal for Thistle after the ball had cannoned off Williamson's back from a colleague's shot. Aberdeen improved and frequently had Jackson in action, Bruce in particular having a fine try deflected, and just on the interval Yorston appeared to be set for scoring when he was dropped in the penalty area, but the referee made no award. Thistle easily retained their lead of five goals until half-time.
WEAKNESS IN FRONT.Aberdeen were forced on the defensive in the early stages of the second period, and in a raid by Thistle, Ness was injured and had to be carried off. He resumed shortly afterwards, but was lame. Aberdeen frequently attacked, but were weak in front of goal, Yorston, Love, McDermid, and Smith all shooting astray when well placed. On another occasion Smith with only the Thistle goalkeeper in front shot into his arms. In the later stages Thistle again became dangerous in attack, and after McDougall had netted from among a crowd of players, Salisbury made the total seven with a tremendous shot, Blackwell never seeing the ball. Ness and O'Hare both left the field before the finish.
Source: Press & Journal, 7th November 1927