Livi kicked off, but Aberdeen had the first opportunity when Bisconti tried a speculative 20-yard effort in the opening minute, which went inches over Culkin?s cross bar. The Dons went close again in the 5th minute after some fine passing play. McAllister delivered a dangerous cross from the left and Mackie headed just over. Aberdeen went close again in the 11th minute as the Dons continued to take the game to Livingston. McAllister and Young set up Eugene Dadi and the Ivory Coast player was fouled on the edge of the box. He still managed to steer the ball into the path of Mackie and he was again inches high with his shot.
Livingston then took the lead against the run of play when Esson brought down Bingham inside the penalty area. Wilson sent the keeper the wrong way as Livi scored with their first shot at goal. They nearly doubled their lead three minutes later when Wilson went close after a mistake by Solberg. Aberdeen were not going to crumble this time and continued to have the bulk of the possession. Winters went close in the 21st minute when he broke into the box and was denied by the left leg of Culkin.
Aberdeen made a whirlwind start to the second period as they pushed for the equaliser. Both Dadi and Mackie had early chances as the home side were pinned back. The Dons should have equalised in the 49th minute when Winters broke on the left and Mackie failed to steer his cross on target. Once more though, the Dons were caught by a sucker punch when Tosh hit a volley from the edge of the box, which left Esson helpless. Good play between Mackie and Winters in the 55th minute saw Hart make a last gasp challenge to concede a corner. From the kick the ball broke to Tiernan on the edge of the box and his fierce shot was blocked in a crowded box.
Livingston brought on Fernandes and Lowndes in the 77th minute as they stepped up a gear. Two minutes later Tosh should have shot but elected to cross and lost the advantage. Aberdeen replaced the tiring Tiernan with McNaughton in the 80th minute. The Dons broke in the 82nd minute and McNaughton delivered the perfect cross for Dadi. Unfortunately the Ivory Coast man made a complete mess of the header. McAllister was stretchered off in the 84th minute and was replaced by Anderson. Darren Mackie should have made it 3-2 to the Dons with the last kick of the game. A brilliant passing movement between Dadi, Thornley and Mackie ended with the striker having only Culkin to beat. His shot went agonisingly wide of the target and the game ended 2-2 but pride was restored.