Source: Glasgow Herald, 26th November 1932
Disjointed Attack.
The Saints half-back trio supported their forwards in fine style, but fortunately for Aberdeen, the forwards' response was poor. Not one carried a really dangerous shot, although their work in the outfield was neat enough. Aberdeen, too, were frequently seen in the role of attackers, but the work of the forwards was disjointed, and with the Perth defence at the top of their form they were seldom dangerous. Like St Johnstone, the Dons were seen at their best against the wind. They held the advantage territorially, but during this period, too, there was a lack of uniformity in attack. With a draw appearing inevitable, Aberdeen in the closing stages brought all they had into an effort to save the day, but the Perth men, although sorely pressed at times, refused to surrender.Moore Missed.
The conditions did not suit Armstrong, who deputised for the injured Moore. The ex-Port-Glasgow junior was nothing if not eager, but he could not hold the line so well as Moore, and he lacked the Irishman's opportunism. Moore was badly missed. All the onus cannot be placed on the reserve leader's shoulders, however, for of the other four attackers only Beattie revealed anything like his best form. The ex-Hall, Russell's player strove time end again to rally Aberdeen's forces, but to no avail. Beattie figured in one the best incidents of the game - a solo effort in which be beat three men - but he was dispossessed at the last moment. McLean and Warnock, the extreme wingers, showed smart touches, but were not consistent. Mills was a trifle disappointing, and was not a patch on the Mills that had the hat trick against Clyde.Heroic Defenders.
Falloon was a tower of strength in the home defence, and was the pick of the Aberdeen middle-men. The Irishman was injured in the second half, and was crippling badly before the finish. Neither Godfrey nor Fraser gauged the wind properly, with the result that their passes were inaccurate. Smith, Cooper, and McGill comprised a sound and capable rear trio. The 'keeper had not a great deal to do, but he deserves credit for two great saves in the second period, from Mason and McEachran. Cooper gave a splendid display, and vied with Welsh for the honour of being the bent back afield. He was sure in his tackles and accurate in his clearances.Confident Saint.
McLaren, in the St Johnstone goal, dealt confidently with what few shots came his way, and Welsh was the better of a pair of first-class backs. The Intermediate line as whole was good, with Priestley outstanding. The attack was the only department that did not impress. Of the quintette, Dickie, the ex-Pittodrie lad, was most prominent, with Ritchie a close second.Source: Press & Journal, 28th November 1932