Aberdeen made a positive start to this match as Nicholson drilled a Lovell pass inches wide of the target in the 2nd minute. A minute later Colin Samuel threatened the Dons goal but Langfield made a comfortable save. The home side then won the first corner of the match in the 5th minute and it required a brave block from Russell Anderson to keep United out. Two minutes later Griffin released Lovell from a free kick but his cross was cut out by Stillie as the game continued at a cracking pace. McNaughton then tested Stillie before United won their third corner kick of the match in the 10th minute.
From the set play the home side worryingly won the header unchallenged but fortunately the cut back wasn't collected by any Tangerine Shirts. The Dons then raced up field to win their first corner of the match, which ended with Byrne being penalised as he headed wide. Aberdeen went close again in the 17th minute when Stillie failed to hold a Nicholson effort but McNaughton fired the rebound over the top before United stormed forward and put the Dons defence under immense pressure. A dangerous cross from McNaughton in the 24th minute was scrambled away by Mulgrew for a corner but once again Byrne was penalised as the ball was delivered into the area.
Fernandez almost grabbed a hat trick in the 43rd minute when Langfield tipped his free kick over the bar. United were in total control by this stage as the Dons struggled to create anything in front of goal. They did win a free kick in the final minute but Smith's delivery was easily cleared allowing Samuel to break quickly forcing Langfield to gather the ball at the feet of the United strikers.
Foster replaced Dempsey in the 46th minute and won a free kick after two minutes. Nicholson then won the first corner of the half from the subsequent free kick but it was easily cleared. Aberdeen were looking lively now and forced a second corner in the 50th minute and a third and fourth a minute later. Unfortunately none of these set plays produced the elusive early goal that Aberdeen were looking for. Griffin was then in action with a great tackle to deny Samuel as United looked to kill the tie with a third goal.
Smith broke at pace and fed the ball to Crawford who fired the ball past Stillie to silence the United fans that had heckled him all match and send the red army into raptures. Anderson then had to make a telling tackle on Samuel as United fought to retain the lead they had just lost with the game flowing from end to end. There was then a moment of danger for Aberdeen in the 74th minute when Robson drilled a free kick wide of the Dons goal before Samuel went close a minute later.
Aberdeen then completely turned the match round as Nicholson fired in a third goal in the 80th minute. Fine play by Crawford set up Foster and he delivered to Nicholson who swept the ball into the net for his second Dons goal. Dundee United brought on Lee Miller to try and save the game and Considine replaced goal hero Crawford in the 85th minute to ensure that wouldn't happen. The home side couldn't find a third and Langfield collected a late yellow for time wasting as the Dons held on for a famous victory.