Source: The Scotsman, 25th April 1910
What Crumley got to do he did well, and could not have saved any of the goals he let past. McEwan was the cup-holders' best back, his only fault being a weakness in tackling. Neal was never himself, and did not appear during the second half for some reason or other. Dainty was the star half on the field, both in defence and attack. Comrie ran him close for honours, but Lee was outjockeyed by the left wing, and did not relish it, having to resort to questionable tactics to keep his end up. Hunter worked hard in centre, and was the cup-holders' best forward, Fraser coming next, Langlands and Bellamy being seldom in the hunt at all. Munro who was on trial, could not be described as a success either at outside left or centre. Mutch did not get a great deal to do, one high shot from Dainty being the most dangerous to negotiate. Colman was the better back, Hume being unsteady at the start, but pulled up as time wore on. Wilson and Millar tied for honours in the middle line, while Davidson has done better many a time, and did not shine against Dundee on Saturday. We got an idea of what the left wing can do, and the pity is they do not give us the same play every week; we would be pleased. They easily carried off the honours. Tom Murray and Bobby Simpson were good and bad by turns with Bert Murray doing nothing in particular but doing it very well. The first half was productive of some good play, but it fell away very much after the second period had gone a bit. Dundee were somewhat disappointed at the smallness of the gate, which was the lowest since the clubs met under League auspices.
Chatty BitsAberdeen left for their northern tour on Tuesday forenoon, when they played Forres on the same evening. On Wednesday they were at Inverness, and to-day (Thursday) they play Buckie. It is rather doubtful if Bert Murray will be able to play this week, as he got a severe shake up in the Dundee match, and feels quite sore all over. The latest from Pittodrie is that Colman and Hume have signed on for another term, and that others are expected to follow their example before Saturday. This will be good news, if true. It is stated that Mutch intends to remain another season, and if the defence can be retained, Aberdeen need have little anxiety for the others. There is no doubt about it there will be several changes in the team next season, and we quite agree that "new blood" is urgently needed, especially in the scoring line. The agreement between the Northern League and the Scottish League as to recognition of signed players closes the door to players shifting at their own sweet will if they do not get their terms. If Aberdeen do not hurry up with signing on players, they will be unable to take part in the Charity ties. It has been decided to play for the Fleming Charity Shield in the close season, the first game taking place on Saturday week. The final for the Dewar Shield will close the serious business for the season at Pittodrie, and we expect to see a rousing final. Falkirk were anxious that the final should be played at Brockville Park, and so were Aberdeen eager to get a good fixture to wind up the season with. It is doubtful if Nichol will be fit to play in the Dewar Shield final, and if he has not sufficiently recovered, Mackay will take his place. Hannah is [not] expected to be fit, and it may be pointed out that this is the first game the popular right back has missed in three years.
Source: Bon-Accord, 28th April 1910
TIRED DUNDEEPittodrie enthusiasts proved the popularity of the Dundee team as cup-holders by giving the Tayside men a hearty welcome as they took the field, but perhaps the anticipations of the crowd in regard to the game were too great. At any rate, when the whistle sounded a cessation, there was keen disappointment on all hands with the afternoon's display, for it certainly was not the "Derby" that the Aberdeen following generally enjoyed on such an occasion. This, of course, was scarcely to be expected, in view of the strenuous struggle through which the visitors have recently passed, four on Saturday they were palpably a tired lot beyond exertion, and evidently indifferent on the matter of league points. Lee was lucky to commence with in securing a wind and sun advantage at the start, but from the opening movements it was apparent that Dundee were done up, and accordingly the Pittodrie eleven as a whole had only a stubborn, but none too steady defence to contend with. When the first point came it was only a fitting capping of the Aberdeen attack, which had come mainly through the left wing, where Millar kept his forwards pair well plied with the ball. It was really O'Hagan goal, but the honour fell to Tom Murray, who was presented with the ball and only Crumley before him. The keeper made a good effort to avert disaster, but the home pivot had too much room to work upon and made no mistake. Naturally drawing of the first blood rows to Dundee from their lethargic state, and Lee and Comrie really did well, but Bellamy was the only one of the fagged forwards who seemed to respond. Fraser's equaliser was a gift goal from a foul kick and at the interval it would have been hard on Aberdeen to be without a lead. O'Hagan saw to that, however, and scored brilliantly just before the whistle went.
TWO WEAK SIDESTo further weaken the fatigued Dundonians they had to turn out for the second period without Neal, who had been obviously lame, and as Aberdeen's strength was on the left, it provided an opening in the most vulnerable point. This was soon made Hannah fest, and had the locals taken full advantage of their opportunities - the finish was decidedly off the mark - and much heavier toll in the matter of goals would have been demanded of Crumley. With the exception of a few occasional efforts Dundee were lying down to the attack, and when Wilson got a third point for the homesters no one was surprised. Bert Murray left the field at this stage, suffering from an injury to his back, which probably accounted for the failure of the usually clever right wing. It would be scarcely fair to criticise the Dundonians after what they have come through, but their middle line is worthy of praise as the division that showed real stamina and fight. Lee and Comrie were strong in the tackle, and while dainty was perhaps weak here, he made up for the deficiency with some rare shooting. Bellamy was clever as a forward along with Fraser, who was out of his position, but the great Sailor Hunter did not seem to exert himself sufficiently to warrant close attention bestowed on him by Wilson. Neal was handicapped, and McEwan was decidedly off colour. Had the opposition been that usually provided by Dundee, Aberdeen's form would never have given them the victory. Mutch did a deal of good saving, for when the Taysiders did attack the generally did so to some purpose. Colman was not much in trouble, but his partner found Bellamy a big handful. Of the halves, Wilson was most prominent in the second half, and Millar was responsible for initiating most of the left wing rates, where O'Hagan sparkled. Tom Murray and Simpson and Bert Murray were not often seen to advantage, and there was a general lack of cohesion in the movement of the front line. On the whole, the result could not have been otherwise, but the circumstances were exceptional, and the least weak of two weak sides one. There was an attendance of about 8000, representing drawings to the amount of £190.
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 25th April 1910