At Torry the above clubs met to play their tie in the first round of the Scottish Cup competition. Messrs Aitchieson and Anderson were the linesmen. The weather was favourable to the game, and a large crowd assembled, testifying to the great interest taken in the event. The spin of the coin favoured the Victoria, and the Orion kicked off against a slight breeze.
Quickly getting on the ball the Victoria ran down to the Orion goal, but the defence was good and the pressure was relieved. Individual effort prevailed on both sides, and as a result, little of a dangerous nature came the way of either of the goalkeepers until Turner from the wing sent in a shot, which bounded off the Orion uprights into play. During almost the whole of the first half the Victoria pressed their opponents; who relieved their charge now and again by a visit to the other end. A foul against the Orion close in looked rosy for the Victoria, but the ball went sailing through the posts from the free kick with¬out being touched, and was resultless, and although the Victoria had obtained four corners they could not score. Half-time result: No goals.
After the usual interval the game was renewed, and the Orion supporters were in a happier vein, as their team had now the advantage of the wind. On several occasions the excitement in this period was very strong, the ball travelling rapidly from end to and, and both goals had narrow escapes. Fifteen minutes from time the Victoria spurted, and it looked as though they were to be successful, but they were sent to the right about, and when time was announced the Orion were round the Victoria goal. Neither team having gained any advantage, the result was a draw. As is usual in cup ties, the play suffered in consequence of the excitement of the players. The Victoria had considerably the best of the play, and, with a little more judgment, might have won; but, with the replay at Central Park, the Orion may be expected to make a stiffer fight. Coming to the players, the principal weakness on both sides was the forwards, especially the left wing, but all were selfish. This may be partially accounted for by the good display of the half backs, who all did yeoman service. Ririe was the shining light in the back division, although Foote and Edwards both played well. The goalkeepers were on a par.
Source: Aberdeen Journal, 7th September 1891