The match between the Aberdeen and Orion at Central Park in the second round of the Scottish Qualifying Cup proved a good draw; and as the Victoria United were playing away at Dundee, a large crowd lined the enclosure. The supporters of the Aberdeen were confident in the success of their team, especially after the display which they gave the previous Saturday. Before the match commenced, the Orion lodged a protest on account of Thomson having taken part in an eleven a-side competition at Barry Camp in the close season. After the boots of the teams had been duly inspected by the referee, they lined up as follows:?Aberdeen: Joe Davidson; John Davidson, McConnachie; Mackie, Henderson, Thomson; Livingston, Cameron, Fullerton, McKay, Shiach. Orion: Watson; Scott, Ross; Wilson, Low, Currie; Hogg, Stopani, Barron, Grant, McPherson. Referee: Mr Spence, Glasgow.
The Aberdeen won the toss, and the Orion kicking off down the hill at once bore down by means of a long forward pass by Hogg on the left. The parting shot went wide, however, and danger was averted. The Whites essayed to push their way uphill, but the incline told against the niceties of passing. The Stripes were playing a strong dashing game, and Davidson now and then experienced an anxious time. Still, the Aberdeen were by no means content to act on the defensive, and Shiach on the right and Livingstone on the left were prominent for good runs; and at last a rather easy shot from the foot of Fullerton found the net, amid the frantic cheers of the Aberdeen supporters. Nettled by this reverse, the Orion strove hard to equalise; and a series of fierce assaults looked threatening for Davidson. For a time the attack was warded off, but at length, coming in a body, the Orion swarmed round the homesters' goal, and the ball, after bobbing about from head to head, was headed past Davidson. From the restart, both teams strained every nerve to obtain a lead, and the play ranged rapidly from end to end. After a lull in the game, the Whites took up the running, but only for a brief spell; and amidst cries of "Come away, Orion," the Stripes burst away in irresistible style. Hogg crossed to Grant, and that player out-pacing the backs found himself with only Davidson to beat. Shooting on the run, he made no mistake, and gave Davidson no chance to save, with a low, oblique shot. End-to-end play followed, the ball travelling with the greatest rapidity from goal to goal, but the Orion were playing the stronger game, there being no sting in the attack of the Whites. A few minutes before half-time the best bit of play so far was seen when the Stripes carried the ball down by a series of sharp see-saw manoeuvres. The finishing touch was equally quick, McPherson shooting across from near the goal line, and Barron bundling the ball through. Shortly after, the whistle went with the score: Orion 3, Aberdeen 1.
On resuming the hopes of the Aberdeen supporters again rose. The Whites went down in a body, and the ball was shot past Watson from a scrimmage close in. The Whites redoubled their efforts from the restart, and play raged fast and furious. Next blood came from the other side, however, and as the result of a raid on Davidson's end, Low secured, and beat that custodian close in. For the next 10 minutes play never flagged, give and take play of a lively nature being the order of the day. At last the Aberdeen, who had been improving in their play considerably, assumed the upper hand, and kept up a prolonged pressure. Ultimately, the Orion again resumed the offensive, and from a scrimmage close in the ball was sent past Davidson for the fifth time. The hopes of the Aberdeen supporters had already begun to fall, but their cup was now full. No more scoring took place, however, and the game ended: Orion, 5; Aberdeen, 2.
Source: Aberdeen Journal, 26th September 1898