Source: The Scotsman, 3rd January 1921
Aberdeen's Weak Finishing.
Dundee were not at all a formidable combination, and the danger threatened to the home goal did not materialise from the expected sources, so well did the Aberdeen defence do its work. The Dark Blues' wing men although getting ample opportunity to shine, made little of the chances they got, and in the inside positions there was a lack of the subtle brain required to make the openings for a centre forward whose record testifies to his goal-getting abilities. On the home side there was much crafty work by the forwards, and especially by the right wing, but the line was not too well balanced, and at times their physical efforts excelled their braininess. Thus the detects of both teams were in the attack, but Dundee were not so strong at half-back as Aberdeen were, and their backs muddled through what often looked a hopeless task. That the Dundee defence was not pierced was largely due to their ability to cover up. Their half-backs had the difficulties of their task increased by the failure of their forwards to reciprocate the efforts at constructive work of their wing halves?l say wing halves, because while Nicol was a great power in defence, his parting efforts put both teams on equal terms in the race for possession. In each of their last three games Aberdeen have accounted for the bulk the pressure, and yet they have had to be content successively with a draw, a defeat, and a draw. The cause is obvious. They lack someone who can combine the "art" of goalscoring with aptitude in leading the attack. The outstanding players in Saturday's match were Forsyth, A. R. Grosert, MacLachlan, Thomson, and Middleton for Aberdeen, and Gibbon, Thomson, Nicol, Irving, and McLean for Dundee.Play in Brief.
In the first half, as in the second, Aberdeen did most of the attacking. The game opened as it finished?fast, but it took some time before communication was established with either goalkeeper, and several shots had gone wide before Gibbon saved from Thomson, and later Connon just missed with a great shot on the run, and Dundee keeper knocked down a drive from Thomson. At the other end Bell gave Honeyman an opportunity, but the winger failed to gather. There was a melee in front of the Dundee goal, and after Gibbon had fisted clear, Connon drove over, and this was followed by a narrow escape for the Dundee goal when Flanaghan just missed with a surprise shot. Bell worked through the Aberdeen defence, but his parting shot was wide, and Anderson was only called into action after half an hour's play, when he fisted away from Troupe. Connon on one occasion dribbled through to a scoring position, but with his final effort completely missed his kick. Just on the interval Aberdeen got the ball in the net after Flanaghan had a shot blocked below the bar, but the goal was struck off on account of some infringement.Sturdy Dundee Defence.
The Dundee attack was more in evidence in the opening period of the second half, when Troupe shot wide from a good position and Bell had several shots charged down. Rankine was nearly through for Aberdeen, but Thomson saved at the cost of a corner. Ultimately Aberdeen set up a sustained pressure on the Dundee goal, and corner after corner fell to their lot without result, Raitt, Thomson, and Gibbon doing great work in the visiting defence. The keeper fisted away from Middleton, and had a brilliant close-range save from Thomson, and many efforts were blocked during scrimmages in front of the Dundee goal. From a break-away McDonald just missed the mark for Dundee. Towards the close Aberdeen redoubled their efforts to score, and Gibbon had magnificent saves from Flanaghan and Thomson.Big Attendance.
Judging by the attendace, it is evident that the early kick-off suited the majority. Fully 20,000 paid for admission to the ground, and with season tickets and others there would have been over 21,000 looking on.Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal 3rd January 1921