Source: The Scotsman, 20th October 1924
STRONG DUNDEE DEFENCE.The strength of Dundee lay in defence. They hid a reliable if not brilliant goalkeeper in Britton, who was ready for all emergencies, albeit an upright came to his assistance on one occasion, and his goal had several narrow escapes off "headers" by Rankin. Thomson gave a brilliant display at right back, and was the best back afield. Not only did he show fine judgment in keeping the Aberdeen right wing at bay, but was responsible for his team's scheme of defence, and his aptitude for being in the right place at a critical moment prevented Aberdeen from scoring on at least two occasions. Brown, if not crafty, gave him whole-hearted assistance. McNab, who made his debut for the Dundee first eleven, gave a splendid account of himself at centre-half. A tremendous worker, he broke up repeated Aberdeen attacks, and rendered valuable service with head and feet in getting rid of many dangerous balls from the Aberdeen wingers. Irving, at right half, played judiciously, and Coyle, on the other side of the field, owed his success largely to his co-operation with Thomson. Although occasionally dangerous, the Dundee attack was distinctly inferior to that of Aberdeen. Knox, on the right, was inclined to be too individualistic, and McLean, at inside right, if showing craft on occasion, was slow. Duncan might have been a greater source of danger to the Aberdeen defence had he been better supported. At inside left Hunter got away some nice passes, but McDonald spoilt his effectiveness by failing to get the ball more frequently across, and the line suffered, like Aberdeen, by the absence of a really dangerous shootest.
STORY OF THE GAME.Dundee were responsible for the initial attack, Forsyth repelling an advance by Knox and McLean. The ball travelled quick to the other end, where A. Jackson slipped and failed to get over a centre. Aberdeen kept up the pressure, and twice Britton had to leave his goal and go to the assistance of his backs. W. Jackson wriggled through, and was in the act of shooting when Britton grabbed the ball. He fell and lost possession, but Thomson went to the rescue. A raid by the Dundee left finished with Blackwell diverting a shot by McDonald, and following this the Aberdeen goal had a narrow escape. Blackwell was drawn out, and it looked as if a shot from Duncan would find the net, but Forsyth, on the goal-line, deflected the ball against the crossbar, and Blackwell, who had returned into goal, cleared from the rebound. Aberdeen again took up the attack and virtually stormed the Dundee defence. A. Jackson, W. Jackson, and Smith all had shots blocked by defenders, and off a centre from the right Rankin, with a header, missed the goal by the narrowest of margins. Keeping up the attack, it seemed Aberdeen would be bound to score, but the visitors concentrated in front of goal, where Thomson and McNab did great work. A hard shot by Paton was finely saved by Britton, and Smith crashed the ball against an upright. The Dundee goal enjoyed more good luck when Rankin twice headed inches wide. Hutton, too, joined in the attack and battered a couple of hard drives against defenders. At length the pressure on the Dundee goal was relieved by McLean and Knox indulging in a raid, but Blackwell cleared the inside forward's try. In another rush by Aberdeen. W. Jackson netted, but offside had previously been sounded. A free kick by Hutton was deflected for a corner, and following it Rankin headed over. Knox was generously plied on the Dundee right, but was well held by Forsyth, and the Aberdeen pressure continued almost unbroken until the interval, when Dundee were fortunate to be level, although deserving credit for their plucky defence.
SECOND-HALF EQUALITY.Aberdeen resumed in promising fashion, and Irving cleared after A. Jackson had centred. McLean endeavoured to get through for Dundee, and the Aberdeen goal was endangered when in clearing J. Jackson kicked the ball against him and it rebounded wide of Blackwell's charge. A centre by McDonald was headed into Blackwell's hands by Duncan, and a faulty pass back by J. Jackson gave the visitors a corner, off which Hutton cleared. For a time play was largely confined to midfield, but the Dundee goal was the first to be endangered, a shot by Alec Jackson missing by inches. Aberdeen maintained the attacks for a spell, and Paton dribbled three opponents but lost possession. Knox, for Dundee, had a long sprint, and reached favourable position for shooting, but, harassed by Forsyth, he sent behind, and later Duncan and McLean both shot wildly. Subsequently each side attacked in turn, but neither goalkeeper was seriously tested. There were stoppages for minor injuries to players on both sides. The most serious of these befell J. Jackson, but he was able to resume after an absence of a few minutes. Britton saved off Paton's head at the expense of a corner, and following the taking of this the keeper saved from Jackson. For Dundee, McLean had a chance, but, with only Blackwell in front, sent wide, and at the visitors' end Aberdeen were dangerous, when Dundee found relief through the medium of a free kick for Paton illegally charging the goalkeeper. Play was fast and keen to the end, with the defenders holding the upper hand.
Source: Press & Journal, 20th October 1924