The Aberdeen manager knew that he would have to change his side for the return at Pittodrie as Hamburg were renowned for having a strong defence and there was always the danger of being caught on the break. Aberdeen kept faith with new signing Stewart McKimmie who was to make his European debut for the Dons and the Dons also brought John McMaster back into the starting line up. McMaster's range of passing and craft would be vital for the Dons. Doug Bell was so often the Dons secret weapon in the European arena and he was again in the side.
The game began in a mild drizzle and the visitors gave evidence of their style with some patient, probing build-ups in the opening minutes. Uli Stein was the first keeper to be called in to action after he smothered a neat Strachan lob after fine set up play by McKimmie. The first danger to the Aberdeen goal came when a Magath shot was deflected for a corner off Neil Simpson. From the corner kick Jakobs sent his header over the bar. After eight minutes Willie Miller sent Peter Weir away down the left and his cross was punched clear by Stein. In 16 minutes Bell found McKimmie unmarked and Hewitt did well to set up McGhee. The Dons striker's overhead kick was cleared for a corner. That sparked further pressure by the Dons and Stein saved well from McMaster and Hewitt in quick succession.
Aberdeen resumed the second half with renewed vigour and they were rewarded with the opening goal in 47 minutes. Weir created the opening with a typical 60-yard run, which left Manny Kaltz wallowing at the pace of Weir. Hewitt did not immediately control Weir's cross but he recovered to set up NEIL SIMPSON, who took time to make room for a shot that gave Stein no chance. Aberdeen might have increased their lead twice shortly after the goal. McGhee sent in a fierce angled drive, which was punched over by Stein, and then Hewitt volleyed over the bar. It was all Aberdeen at that point and McGhee saw his header saved by Stein before the Dons brought on Eric Black for John Hewitt in 63 minutes.
The scenes of joy at the end was reflected by a jubilant set of players who took a deserved lap of honour after being presented with the European Super Cup plaque. Never before or since had the Dons profile been so high. No less than 80 countries worldwide had beamed the game from Pittodrie on live television with a similar amount taking in the highlights. In becoming the first and only Scottish side to win the Super Cup and two European trophies, it was an impressive Aberdeen record. Up to that point in their history Aberdeen had won 27 of their 55 Euro ties with 13 drawn, and the game against Hamburg was the 12th time in 27 European ties that the opposition had been denied a score.
Manager Ferguson was a happy manager. "In the first half we allowed them too much room. However that was sorted out at the interval and when the first goal came it changed the complexion of the game. We began to really hurt them in the second half and Weir was giving Kaltz a real doing. Gordon Strachan showed all of his arrogance and he was a major factor in our second half performance."