Source: The Scotsman, 8th December 1913
TWO SIMPLE GOALSAberdeen started off in promising style, but the flattered only to deceive. Soye, McLeod, and Robertson were prominent in some clever combined work, and McLeod on two occasions in the opening stages came near to scoring, and Walker, after tricking two opponents, sent narrowly behind. First Goodwin then Cunningham put in some good work for Kilmarnock, and it was a lovely effort on Cunningham's part which resulted in Greig effecting a clever save, while he also did well to hold a snap shot from Culley. For a time Aberdeen kept up a strong pressure. Roberts and sent over a good square, and Soye kept footing the ball well into the centre, but the Kilmarnock defence held out. McLeod had one good try, but just missed, and Wilson also had a creditable try. After Greig had saved from Neil and Cunningham, Aberdeen took the lead in sensational style. Grant left his goal to field a high return by Colman, but misjudged the flight of the ball, and walker put into an empty goal. Kilmarnock were prominent after this, and Neil the equalized with a header, the Aberdeen goalkeeper, under the impression that the scorer was offside, making no attempt to save. Aberdeen pressed for the later period of the half, but had to be content with an equal division of goals at the interval.
VISITORS SUPERIORAfter an initial burst in the second half, Aberdeen fell away considerably. A mistake by Hannah allowed Culley through, but the centre, hampered by Colman, failed to improve upon the chance. Greig did well to clear a good try from Culley later, and Neil also shot well. Aberdeen were a spasmodic lot, but Walker and McLeod both had good tries, which Grant cleared. With 20 minutes to go Kilmarnock took the lead. Culley worked well down between the backs, and Neil, taking advantage of a momentary hesitation on their part, rushed in and crash the ball past Greig. After this reverse, Aberdeen placed Wyllie at centre forward, Walker going centre half. The change was not productive of any better results, however. Kilmarnock continued to monopolise the play, but once Wyllie almost rushed through the equaliser. Aberdeen could not break down the solid defence of the visitors, who, in the end, gained a merited victory. Aberdeen were best represented by Colman, Hannah, Wilson, and McLeod, and Kilmarnock by Mitchell, Waddell, Neil, and Cunningham.
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 8th December 1913