When the teams lined up for the eleventh county final, it was seen that there was a stranger in both ranks. Sword, of Arbroath, occupied Jim Thorn's place, and Jinkins, Elgin City, was intrusted with Aberdeen's centre position. Orion opened sensationally. From the kick off they worked through the Whites' defence, and scored less than a minute from the start. Aberdeen took up the running, and kept their opponents on the defensive. This state of matters continued during nearly all the first half, Orion rarely getting near Ritchie. From a corner Aberdeen equalised, and before the interval Jinkins gave them the lead with a grand shot. With the wind, and only one goal down, Orion were confident of soon wiping off the leeway. Aberdeen started and made for McBean. Clark, who had taken up the centre position, had a good chance, but shot wide. From a grand run by Aberdeen, Joe Davidson sent in a hard shot which McBean cleared, but Clark got on the ball and banged it into the net. Notwithstanding the gale, Aberdeen were having as much of the game as their opponents, and were easily worth another point or two. Towards the finish Orion made a determined effort, and Hogg was successful. From this point to the close Orion pressed, but the Whites' defence could not be pierced, and Aberdeen secure the cup once more by 3 goals to 2.
Short Kicks.
The destination of the cup for another year was decided before an £88 gate. Aberdeen we think pressed rather strongly. They would have scored oftener in the first half had they kept the game more open. Sword, Arbroath (Thom's substitute), started all right, but got rather forcible, and was the means of giving Aberdeen a number of free kicks. The Whites were better served with Jenkins. He put in a lot of good work, and scored the second goal with a beautiful shot. Tom Robertson kept the game finely in hand. Nothing escaped him. The Northern League ought to send their crowd of referees to him for lessons. Tom goes to Ireland this week to referee the Irish v. English international. We have to thank the Vics for the great improvement they have made on the press box. It is now as comfortable as one would wish. The alterations have evidently been carried out by he who knew what he was doing. Again thanks, gentlemen. Aberdeen's chances did not look so rosy when the second half started. With the wind against them and only a goal to the good, there was a general shaking of heads amongst their supporters. Orion seemed completely at sea without Thom. However poorly Jim plays he seems to inspire the forward line with confidence. Without him on Saturday they were like lost sheep. Billy Clark went centre for Aberdeen during the second half, and the change worked wonders. Jim Mackie had a solo run the entire length of the field. Allan Scott was too much for him when he got to close quarters. Aberdeen had the trophy the first three years it was in existence. 89-90 was the last time their name was inscribed on it. It was just about time for their turn. Without doubt the best team won on the day's play. Aberdeen all over played a superior game to their opponents. Billy Clark was the best forward on the field, and gave his wings plenty of work. His form was a revelation to a few. Jim Mackie also was at concert pitch. All over, the Whites gave a grand display. Hogg was Orion's best man, but the front line suffered for want of a capable centre. Aberdeen had the smallest forward line that ever played in a final. There was not a heavy weight amongst the five. After the match the cup was presented in the Waverly Hotel, Mr Walker (Orion) presiding. Mr Blann accepted the trophy for the Whites. The usual toasts were given and heartily responded to. When Tom Robertson's health was proposed he received quite an ovation. In replying, he remarked that the play was wonderfully good for a final. When the news of the Vics' success at Forfar was known, the Blues present were congratulated right and left. Secretary Jaffray instructed the preparing of the pitch to Inspector Findlay, and the work was carried out admirably.
Source: Bon-Accord, 3rd March 1898
Source: Aberdeen Journal, 28th February 1898